Updated on July 12th, 2026
It is so challenging to find spices without all the contamination or California Proposition 65 warning. Even many popular organic spice brands do carry the CA Prop 65 warning for detected lead or other heavy metals. The challenge is finding a supplier that sources their spices in lead-contaminated lands; many plants are naturally more prone to gather heavy metals from the ground! Same for coffee and chocolate; many brands sell them anyway without bothering to search for better suppliers other go above and beyond to avoid this risk.
I admire these kinds of brands that take extra steps to ensure their products are safer and healthier, and that are the brands I want to support! Like these ones listed on this page!
❌ Avoid conventional nutmeg full of pesticides, and glyphosate and packed in plastic packing
❌ Avoid greenwashing nutmeg made by brands that pretends to be organic, safer, or healthier, when they are not. They will use their misleading marketing tricks to convince you to but their products.
Glyphosate (Roundup’s active ingredient) has been detected in some nutmeg samples, including organic ones, potentially from post-harvest drying sprays or environmental drift, at levels up to 50 parts per million in isolated tests.
One brand tested over 1,200 parts per billion of lead, which means a single gram could exceed the daily warning limit by 140%.
WARNING: This product can expose you to chemicals including Lead and lead compounds which are known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov
I wanted a better and safer nutmeg that was organic and without heavy metals.
Here you will find the best organic nutmeg brands without heavy metals that trigger the California Proposition 65 warning.
Shop with my links to support my research!💖
10% off code: PRETTYORGANICGIRL
🌿Evermill is an approved organic spice brand!
I admire brands that take extra steps to ensure their products are safer and healthier, and that are the brands I want to support! Like this one! I connected with the founders, and they know all about the dirty insights that the space industry faces. They are sourcing safer spice products since they could not find them for themselves; they decided to take over and offer this solution to others as well.
🌿This organic nutmeg spice is USDA Certified Organic and packed in a beautiful glass jar. To avoid single-use plastic containers or cups that end up in landfills, they offer organic spice compostable refills.
🌿 Evermill is committed to environmental sustainability in all the spices they source. I recommend their entire spice line.
All Evermill spices are 100% organic: grown on land free of synthetic fertilizers, growth regulators, insecticides, or herbicides for at least three years. And they are ethically sourced with a verified supply chain. Evermill spices are sourced by the best suppliers in the United States. They are grown all around the world, and the countries of origin vary depending on the individual spice, which is the best known.
INGREDIENTS: Organic Nutmeg
🍃Starwest Botanicals collection is full of USA-certified organic herbs, spices, teas, essential oils, and botanical blends.
It is one of the largest suppliers of organic botanicals in the country: Starwest began as a small herb shop in Sacramento, California, in 1975. They milled their herbs, sourced directly from around the world, and built trust with farmers and suppliers. Pioneers in the organic herb movement, herb quality, and herb transparency.
Since 1989, they have been a Certified Organic Processor: all of our organic products have been grown and harvested in accordance with the USDA National Organic Program. Kosher Certified Facility.
Starwest Botanicals products are tested for authenticity and safety in-house laboratories and independent labs. Certificates of Analysis (C of A’s) are available upon request.
Testing includes organoleptic analysis for aroma, color, flavor, and texture. Physical testing involves moisture, volatile oil content, heavy metals, microbiology, thin layer chromatography, and other tests specific to each herb.
INGREDIENTS: Nutmeg Powder, Origin: India/Indonesia